What is most immediately distinctive about Edgar's work, certainly among poets of his generation, is his commitment to formal verse "and for showing considerable panache in handling [it]" (Kevin Hart, Oxford Companion to Twentieth-Century Poetry). This has drawn comparisons, in Australia, with poets such as A D Hope and Gwen Harwood, but also to the likes of Anthony Hecht and Richard Wilbur. Poetry Chicago says of him that "he achieves, overall, a supple classicism that earns him a place next to the best twentieth-century American formalists."
A reviewer once dryly observed that Edgar's work gives the impression that he spends a lot of time looking out of windows, and indeed an Edgar poem is often an extended meditation in which a visual surface, whether a natural scene or social occasion or painting, is "probed and questioned in the most delicately nuanced ways" (Paul Stevens, The Chimaera). His imagination "inhabits the enigmatic and the transient - the 'going... going...' of things which refuse nonetheless to be gone" (Peter Steele) and "the labyrinth just behind Creation's serene surface" (Alan Gould). As this description may imply, much of his work is objective and impersonal in character, at least in so far as Edgar generally avoids intruding as an actor in his own poems. Nevertheless, he has also written numerous poems of a more personal and passionate character, especially in recent years. The most notable example may be the sequence "Consume My Heart Away" from his book Other Summers, described by one reviewer as "pretty much as good as anything in the 800-year-old history of love poetry in English" (Geoff Page, ABC Radio National).
In his 2008 CD Photography for Beginners, a selection of his poems ranging over his last 12 years in print, his reading is characterized by clarity and expressiveness, accompanied at times by an understated sense of humour. The CD was recorded on 26 July 2008 for The River Road Press Poetry Series in Sydney, Australia. Producer: Carol Jenkins. Photography for Beginners is available from www.riverroadpress.net/.